JSONToTable

CSV vs TOON: Which One Should You Actually Use?

A straightforward comparison to help you pick the right format

Published: January 2025 • 9 min read

Let's be honest: CSV has been around forever and everyone knows it. Open it in Excel, Google Sheets, or any spreadsheet tool - it just works. So why would you consider TOON instead?

The answer depends on one thing: Are you working with AI models? If you're sending data to GPT-4, Claude, or other LLMs, TOON can cut your token costs significantly. If not, CSV is probably fine. Let me show you exactly when each makes sense.

TL;DR:

  • • CSV: Use for spreadsheets, reports, sharing with non-technical people
  • • TOON: Use when sending data to AI models - saves ~22% tokens vs CSV
  • • For regular apps: Just use CSV, don't overthink it

The Main Differences

Both formats are great for tabular data. Here's what makes each one special:

C

CSV

The universal standard

  • •Opens in literally everything
  • •Super simple - just commas and rows
  • •Everyone already knows how to use it
  • •No extra software needed

BEST FOR:

Excel reports, data exports, sharing with anyone

T

TOON

The AI optimizer

  • •22% fewer tokens than CSV
  • •Built specifically for LLM efficiency
  • •Still human-readable
  • •Includes structure metadata

BEST FOR:

GPT-4, Claude, any LLM where tokens cost money

Same Data, Two Formats

Here's the exact same customer data in both formats. Notice the difference in how they're structured:

Real Token Count:

CSV = 98 tokens | TOON = 76 tokens

Difference: TOON saves you 22 tokens (22% reduction)

CSV Format

98 tokens
id,name,email,plan,mrr,active
1,Sarah Mitchell,[email protected],Premium,299,true
2,Michael Chen,[email protected],Enterprise,999,true
3,Jennifer Kumar,[email protected],Basic,99,false
4,David Park,[email protected],Premium,299,true
5,Emma Wilson,[email protected],Basic,99,true

Good: Simple, universal • Bad: No metadata, LLMs sometimes struggle with context

TOON Format

76 tokens (22% less!)
customers[5]{id,name,email,plan,mrr,active}:
  1,Sarah Mitchell,[email protected],Premium,299,true
  2,Michael Chen,[email protected],Enterprise,999,true
  3,Jennifer Kumar,[email protected],Basic,99,false
  4,David Park,[email protected],Premium,299,true
  5,Emma Wilson,[email protected],Basic,99,true

Good: More efficient, includes metadata • Bad: Need a library, not universal yet

What's Actually Different?

Look at the first line. CSV just lists the headers. TOON adds customers[5]to tell you "hey, this is a customers array with 5 records" and wraps field names in {}.

This extra metadata helps AI models understand the structure better, and surprisingly, it uses fewer tokens because the overall format is more compact. The data rows themselves? Identical in both formats.

Feature-by-Feature Breakdown

Let's be honest about what each format can and can't do:

FeatureCSVTOON
Universally supported?✓ Yes!Not yet
Easy to learn?✓ Super easyPretty easy
Opens in Excel?✓ Yes!Need converter
Good for AI/LLMs?OK✓ Optimized
Token efficient?Good✓ 22% better
Includes metadata?No✓ Yes
Human readable?✓ Very✓ Very
File sizeSmallestVery small

How Token Savings Scale Up

That 22% difference might not sound huge, but it adds up when you're processing lots of data:

Dataset SizeCSV TokensTOON TokensTokens Saved
5 records987622 (22%)
50 records980760220 (22%)
1,000 records19,60015,2004,400 (22%)

CSV Reality Check

CSV is efficient for file storage, but when you're sending it to an LLM, those tokens add up. It's not terrible, just not optimized for this use case.

TOON Advantage

That header line with the metadata? It actually saves tokens by making the format more compact. Weird but true.

What This Actually Costs You

Let's translate those token savings into real money. Using GPT-4 pricing ($0.01 per 1,000 tokens):

Small Side Project

10,000 API calls/month • ~1,000 tokens per call

HOBBY

CSV

$65/mo

TOON

$51/mo

You save

$14/mo

Not huge, but covers your coffee budget

Growing Startup

100,000 API calls/month • ~2,000 tokens per call

GROWTH

CSV

$1,300/mo

TOON

$1,014/mo

You save

$286/mo

$3,432/year - now we're talking

Production Scale

1,000,000 API calls/month • ~3,000 tokens per call

ENTERPRISE

CSV

$19,500/mo

TOON

$15,210/mo

You save

$4,290/mo

$51,480/year saved - that's real money

Real Talk:

If you're doing small-scale stuff, the savings might not be worth the hassle of learning a new format. But if you're processing serious volume? That 22% adds up fast. Use ourCSV to TOON converter to see your exact savings.

So Which Should You Use?

Here's my honest take after working with both:

CStick with CSV When:

✓ You're sharing with non-technical people

Your boss needs to open it in Excel? CSV. Your client wants a data export? CSV. Simple as that.

✓ You're not using AI models

Regular data processing? Database imports? Analytics? Just use CSV. Don't fix what isn't broken.

✓ You need universal compatibility

CSV works everywhere, always. No dependencies, no libraries, no explaining. That's worth something.

TSwitch to TOON When:

✓ You're sending data to LLMs

GPT-4, Claude, any AI model where you pay per token? That 22% savings adds up. Especially at scale.

✓ You're processing high volume

Thousands of API calls per day? Millions per month? Those token savings translate to real money.

✓ You want better AI context

TOON's metadata helps LLMs understand your data structure better. It's not just about tokens.

My Actual Recommendation

Use Both (Seriously)

1

Store and share in CSV

Everyone knows CSV. Use it for your exports, reports, and anywhere humans need to open the file.

2

Convert to TOON for AI

When you need to send data to an LLM, convert it first. Use ourCSV to TOON converter - it's literally one click.

3

Convert back when needed

Got TOON data from an API? Convert it back to CSV for spreadsheet work. The conversion is lossless both ways.

Bottom line: You don't have to choose just one forever. Use CSV as your default, convert to TOON when it saves you money. Best of both worlds.

Free Conversion Tools

Switch between formats anytime:

CSV → TOON

Convert your CSV to TOON format and see how many tokens you'll save

Try it now →

TOON → CSV

Convert TOON back to CSV for spreadsheet compatibility

Try it now →

Want to Learn More?

Related Comparisons

Format Guides

Official Documentation

Format Specs

AI Tools

Back to TOON ArticlesAll Categories